Home News Mastodon’s Decentralized Social Network Faces Significant CSAM Challenge

Mastodon’s Decentralized Social Network Faces Significant CSAM Challenge

by admin
CSAM problem

In the wake of Elon Musk’s takeover of Twitter, Mastodon emerged as a popular alternative due to its decentralized structure, which shields it from the influence of impulsive billionaires. However, the very feature that makes it appealing has now become a major headache as it poses significant challenges to content moderation.

A recent study conducted by Stanford University highlighted the severity of the issue. In just a two-day period, they discovered 112 instances of known child sexual abuse material (CSAM) and nearly 2,000 posts using hashtags associated with abusive content. David Thiel, the researcher behind the study, expressed the magnitude of the problem, stating that they had more photoDNA hits in those two days than they had ever experienced in their entire history of analyzing social media.

One of the core difficulties with decentralized platforms like Mastodon is that there is no central authority governing the entire network. Each instance operates independently, managed by its own administrators who are accountable for the content within their specific instance. Yet, they lack control over what transpires in other instances or servers.

This predicament isn’t exclusive to Mastodon alone; even Meta’s popular Threads, following a decentralized model, faces similar challenges. While Threads aims to be interoperable with ActivityPub, enabling users to interact across platforms like Mastodon, it also confronts the conundrum of inadequate moderation. Unlike Facebook or Instagram, where Meta has more control over moderation, Threads cannot oversee the entire flow effectively.

In response, larger instances on Mastodon and other platforms may consider blocking access to problematic instances, but this approach doesn’t entirely solve the issue. The content remains in existence, merely isolated within specific instances, and requires the moderators of those instances to address its removal.

Ultimately, the decentralized nature of Mastodon presents a significant obstacle in combating CSAM and similar content, calling for innovative solutions to strike a balance between individual instance autonomy and collective efforts to ensure a safer social network environment. We have reached out to Mastodon for comments and will update this story as soon as we receive their response.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) about CSAM problem

What is Mastodon’s decentralized social network?

Mastodon is a decentralized social network that gained popularity as an alternative to Twitter, especially after Elon Musk’s takeover. Its decentralized nature ensures independence from the control of single entities.

What is the CSAM problem faced by Mastodon?

CSAM stands for Child Sexual Abuse Material. Mastodon has been grappling with the presence of CSAM content on its platform, making content moderation a significant challenge.

What did the Stanford study reveal about CSAM on Mastodon?

The Stanford study found 112 matches of known CSAM over a two-day period, with nearly 2,000 posts using hashtags associated with abusive material. This alarming discovery highlights the severity of the problem.

How does Mastodon’s decentralized structure affect content moderation?

Mastodon’s decentralized structure means that each instance has its own administrators, responsible for their specific content. However, they lack control over content on other instances or servers, making comprehensive moderation difficult.

What is Threads and how does it relate to Mastodon’s challenges?

Threads, a platform by Meta, also follows a decentralized model and plans to be interoperable with ActivityPub, allowing interaction with Mastodon. However, similar to Mastodon, Threads faces difficulties in comprehensive moderation due to decentralization.

What solutions have been proposed for handling problematic content on Mastodon?

Some suggest that larger instances could block access to problematic instances, but this wouldn’t entirely resolve the issue. Content may still exist within those instances, and its removal would depend on the moderators of each specific instance.

More about CSAM problem

  • Mastodon – Official website for Mastodon’s decentralized social network.
  • [Elon Musk’s Twitter takeover](Insert reference link here) – A news source covering Elon Musk’s impact on Twitter and the search for alternatives.
  • [Stanford study on CSAM](Insert reference link here) – Details of the study revealing CSAM occurrences on Mastodon over a two-day period.
  • ActivityPub – Information about ActivityPub, the protocol enabling interaction between decentralized platforms like Mastodon and Threads.
  • [Meta Threads](Insert reference link here) – Information on Meta’s Threads, a decentralized platform related to Mastodon’s challenges.
  • [Content moderation challenges](Insert reference link here) – Articles discussing the difficulties of content moderation on decentralized social media platforms.

You may also like


TechGeek42 July 25, 2023 - 2:32 am

Meta Threads, mastodon, decentralized – buzzwords! but they struggle with csam moderation? serious issue. larger instances block access – not the cure! more needs fixing. need proper controls!

SocialMediaSkeptic July 25, 2023 - 6:14 am

Mastodon’s popular as twitter alt, Elon Musk and all that, but csam mess is a major prob. who’s to blame? no one got control! need better ways to stop bad stuff. #MastodonChallenges

TwitterEscapee July 25, 2023 - 1:19 pm

I heard mastodon is like twitter but decentralized, cool right? but now they got this csam thing? not good. who gonna take charge of the mess?? stanford study found bad stuff. need solutions!

socialMediaFan99 July 25, 2023 - 2:45 pm

mastodon seems cool but csam problem big headache. Decentralized means no one’s in charge, so content moderation tough. Stanford study found 112 matches of CSAM in 2 days? that’s cray!


Leave a Comment